Craving something sweet? These Sullivan County bakeries have delicious holiday treats, custom cakes and any sweet you are craving. From traditional Italian pastries to creative cupcake flavors, here’s where to satisfy your sweet tooth.
Check out our IG post with pics & vids.
Floyd & Bobo’s, Liberty Floyd & Bobo’s brings fresh pastries and baked goods to Liberty every morning. They’re not just about sweets – the savory snacks and breakfast items round out the selection. Located in downtown Liberty, they’ve become a morning ritual for locals who know to arrive early for the best selection.
Cuppie Cake Desserts, Jeffersonville Cuppie Cake takes a playful approach to desserts. Their creative weekly specials keep locals guessing what’s next, and the dessert coffees are as Instagram-worthy as they are delicious. The S’Moreo Latte combines s’mores and Oreo flavors in a way that shouldn’t work but absolutely does. They also serve coffee buckets and dirty sodas if you want to try something different.
County Road Bakery, Callicoon County Road Bakery proves that gluten-free doesn’t mean flavor-free. This 100% gluten-free bakery offers both sweet and savory options, making it a haven for those with celiac disease or gluten sensitivity visiting Sullivan County. Their location on Main Street means you can stop in during other Callicoon adventures.
The Walk In, Livingston Manor While The Walk In is famous for their buttermilk biscuits, don’t overlook their sweets. The same scratch-made approach that defines their savory items extends to their dessert menu. Owner Erin Ellis also runs The Stumble Out across the street, giving this corner of Livingston Manor serious food credentials.
The Coffee Way Cafe, Wurtsboro The Coffee Way makes Italian pastries from scratch daily, bringing authentic flavors to Wurtsboro. The thrift shop next door (Synchronicity Gallery) creates an interesting dynamic. People come for coffee and pastries, then browse vintage finds. Or they come to thrift and discover the cafe.
DeFilippis Bakery, Monticello DeFilippis offers the massive selection you’d expect from an established bakery. From simple cookies to elaborate ice cream cakes, they cover every dessert need. This is where Sullivan County residents go for birthday cakes, holiday cookies, and special occasion desserts.
Planning Your Stops These bakeries are spread across Sullivan County, making it easy to find something sweet wherever you’re exploring. Most open early and close by mid-afternoon.
From NYC, these make perfect stops during a Catskills getaway. Each bakery has a unique personality and delicious options worth trying.
We’re always discovering new sweet spots in Sullivan County. What’s your favorite Catskills bakery? We are working on part 3!