Opens in a new tab

Where Should I Stay in the Sullivan Catskills for First-Time Visitors?

The Sullivan Catskills rewards the visitor who is willing to slow down. Arriving here for the first time means choosing not just where to stay but which version of the region you want to experience: a river town with a main street, a quiet valley inn tucked into the woods, a design-forward retreat in the hills. The county has all of these and the choice shapes the whole trip.

Here is a guide to the lodging landscape, organized by town and experience type, for anyone making their first visit to Sullivan County.

Quick Answer: Best Places to Stay in the Sullivan Catskills for First-Timers

First-time visitors to the Sullivan Catskills have several standout lodging options across the county:

  • Arnold House, Livingston Manor: a restored roadhouse with a craft cocktail bar and a strong sense of place; good base for Livingston Manor and the Beaverkill Valley
  • The DeBruce, Livingston Manor: a destination inn and restaurant in a wooded setting along Willowemoc Creek; known for its kitchen and fly fishing access
  • Kenoza Hall, Kenoza Lake: a grand 19th-century hotel restored as a full-service retreat with a pool, spa and farm-to-table restaurant
  • Callicoon Hills, Callicoon Center: a hillside retreat with panoramic views, a pool and a laid-back Hudson Valley sensibility
  • Blue Fox Motel, Narrowsburg: a midcentury motel with 18 accommodations and a rustic-yet-pampered feel, plus an onsite restaurant and bar serving classic American fare made with local ingredients; it sits where the Ten Mile River meets the Delaware, making it a good base for Narrowsburg and the Upper Delaware

Each of these properties has a distinct personality. The right choice depends on whether you are here for the river towns, the food, the outdoors or simply the quiet.

Staying in Livingston Manor

Livingston Manor is the most food-forward town in Sullivan County and a natural hub for first-time visitors who want to explore the full range of what the region offers. It sits at the center of the county with easy access to the Beaverkill, Willowemoc Creek and the surrounding back roads.

Arnold House, Livingston Manor

  • A restored 19th-century roadhouse on the edge of Livingston Manor with rooms, a cocktail bar and a seasonal kitchen
  • The bar program is one of the most distinctive in the county; drinks are made with local ingredients and the room draws a mix of locals and visitors
  • Best for: visitors who want a social base with a lively bar scene and easy access to town
  • Check arnoldhouse.com for room availability and current programming

The DeBruce, Livingston Manor

  • A destination inn set along Willowemoc Creek in Livingston Manor with rooms, a highly regarded kitchen and access to private fly fishing water
  • Known for its farm-sourced tasting menus and a strong commitment to the landscape and local food systems
  • A quieter, more immersive experience than Arnold House; better suited to visitors looking to unplug
  • Best for: food-focused travelers, fly fishing visitors and those wanting a full retreat experience
  • Check thedebruce.com for availability and dining reservations

Staying Near Kenoza Lake

Kenoza Lake sits in the interior of Sullivan County, quieter than the river towns but within easy reach of both Livingston Manor and Callicoon. The lake itself is peaceful and the surrounding countryside has the feel of an older, less-discovered Catskills.

Kenoza Hall, Kenoza Lake

  • A restored 19th-century grand hotel with a pool, spa, tennis courts and a full-service restaurant
  • One of the most complete resort experiences in Sullivan County; everything is on the property
  • Elegant without being stiff; the restoration respects the original bones of the building while adding modern comfort
  • Best for: couples, groups and visitors who want a full resort experience without leaving the property
  • Check kenozahall.com for availability and packages

Staying in Callicoon and the Delaware Valley

Callicoon is Sullivan County’s most visited river town, with a Sunday farmers market, riverfront access, good food and a main street worth wandering. Staying in the Callicoon area puts you within easy reach of the Delaware River, the Narrowsburg art scene and the hillside cidery at Seminary Hill.

Callicoon Hills, Callicoon Center

  • A hillside property with sweeping valley views, a pool and a relaxed, design-forward sensibility
  • Located a short drive above Callicoon in Callicoon Center
  • The property has a casual communal feel that suits friends traveling together as well as couples
  • Best for: visitors who want views, a pool and easy access to Callicoon and the Delaware Valley
  • Check callicoonhills.com for availability and event programming

Staying in Narrowsburg

Narrowsburg sits on a dramatic bend in the Delaware River and has one of the most concentrated arts and culture scenes in Sullivan County. The town is small but walkable, with galleries, independent shops and a handful of strong restaurants within a few blocks of the river.

Blue Fox Motel, Narrowsburg

  • A boutique inn above the Delaware River with a well-regarded restaurant and rooms that balance comfort with local character
  • The restaurant sources locally and changes with the season; dinner reservations are recommended
  • Best for: visitors who want river views and easy access to Narrowsburg’s arts scene
  • Check for availability bluefoxmotel.com and dining reservations

Other Lodging Options in the Sullivan Catskills

Beyond the flagship properties, the Sullivan Catskills has a wide range of vacation rentals, small inns and cabin properties spread throughout the county. Many visitors prefer to rent a house or cabin for the full private-kitchen, private-deck experience that the region is known for.

  • Vacation rentals: Airbnb and Vrbo have strong inventory throughout Sullivan County, particularly around Livingston Manor, Narrowsburg and Callicoon; expect everything from farmhouses to modern mountain cabins
  • Boutique and small inns: several smaller inn-style properties operate throughout the county; the Sullivan Catskills website maintains a current lodging directory
  • Campgrounds and glamping: the county has camping options along the Delaware River and in the state forest preserve; glamping properties have expanded in recent years for visitors who want a nature-forward experience with more comfort

How to Choose Where to Stay in the Sullivan Catskills

The county is larger than it looks on a map. Driving between Callicoon and Narrowsburg takes about 30 minutes; from Livingston Manor to Callicoon is another 30. First-time visitors often underestimate the distances between towns.

  • If you want the most food and cultural options within walking distance: Livingston Manor or Narrowsburg
  • If you want a river town main street with a Sunday farmers market: base in or near Callicoon
  • If you want a full resort with everything on-property: Kenoza Hall
  • If you want the most complete food-and-fly-fishing retreat experience: The DeBruce
  • If you plan to explore widely: choose a central property and accept that you will be driving; most of the county’s highlights are within 30 to 45 minutes of each other

Wherever you stay, a car is essential. The Sullivan Catskills is not a walkable destination in the conventional sense; the reward is the drive itself, through valleys and over ridges that change with every season.

A cozy room featuring a tufted leather sofa, an armchair, large windows, plants, and decorative items on the walls.

Frequently Asked Questions

First-time visitors to the Sullivan Catskills are well-served by any of the county’s established inn properties. Arnold House and The DeBruce in Livingston Manor suit visitors focused on food, cocktails and the Beaverkill Valley. Kenoza Hall near Kenoza Lake is the most complete resort option. Callicoon Hills offers views and a pool in the Delaware Valley. The Blue Fox Motel in Narrowsburg is ideal for visitors who want river access and a walkable arts town. All four towns offer distinct experiences.

Livingston Manor is often recommended for first-timers because it sits at the center of the county and has the most developed food and coffee scene. Callicoon suits visitors drawn to river life and the Sunday farmers market. Narrowsburg appeals to those interested in art, galleries and a compact walkable town. For a full resort experience away from town, Kenoza Hall near Kenoza Lake is its own destination.

 

Yes. The Blue Fox Motel in Narrowsburg is a boutique inn with a well-regarded restaurant, rooms with local character and a walkable location above the Delaware River. It is one of the most distinctive lodging options in the county for visitors who want a river town experience with strong food on-property.

 

Kenoza Hall is a restored 19th-century grand hotel near Kenoza Lake in Sullivan County. The property has been renovated as a full-service retreat with a pool, spa and a farm-to-table restaurant. It is one of the most complete resort experiences in the Sullivan Catskills and suits visitors who want everything on-property.

 

Arnold House is a restored roadhouse in Livingston Manor with guest rooms and one of the most distinctive cocktail bars in the Sullivan Catskills. The bar program uses local ingredients and the property has become a social hub for visitors and locals alike. 

 

Yes. A car is essential for a Sullivan Catskills visit. The county’s towns and attractions are spread across a large rural area and there is no meaningful public transit connecting them. The drive between Livingston Manor and Callicoon takes approximately 30 minutes; between Callicoon and Narrowsburg about the same. Most visitors consider the driving as part of the experience rather than an inconvenience.

Yes. Vacation rentals are one of the most popular lodging options in Sullivan County, with strong inventory on Airbnb and Vrbo across the county. Houses, farmhouses, cabins and converted barns are available in and around Livingston Manor, Callicoon, Narrowsburg and throughout the back roads between towns. Rentals offer private outdoor space, full kitchens and the kind of immersive rural experience that defines a Sullivan Catskills visit.

Make time for what matters.

Your getaway, made easy.

Build My Dream Itinerary
Come see us.

Subscribe to the Sullivan Catskills.